My three selections hit the bull eye, by race
By Asher Butt and Abid Sultan
Seven races produced one book favourite win (Talent Again), my favourite win in the maiden (Pakistani Queen), two place winners, and two fluke winners. The three selections predicted from pre-race form and weight assessment went to the wire.
Book favs hit 1 / 6
My favs hit 1 / 7
Place winners 2
Fluke winners 3
My picks in frame 12 / 21
Race-by-race results
| Race | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | Book fav | My fav |
| R1 · 12:30 Maiden 1000m |
1Jutt Gee | 2Tehran Shan | 3Cheezious | Tiger out | Tiger out |
| R2 · 1:05 Div VII 1000m |
1Zaman Sahib | 2Mid Night Grace | 3Silent Melody | Mid Night Grace 2nd | Mid Night Grace 2nd |
| R3 · 1:40 Div V&VI 1100m |
1Talent Again | 2Wake Up | 3Thunder Pride | Talent Again won | Thunder Pride 3rd |
| R4 · 2:15 Makkah Cup maiden 1100m |
1Pakistani Queen | 2Son of Gujrat | 3Mera Sultan | None declared | Pakistani Queen won |
| R5 · 2:50 November Cup 1400m |
1Bella Two | 2Tomorrowland | 3Queen of Pharaoh | Chasing Eden out | Chasing Eden out |
| R6 · 3:25 Div I&II 1300m |
1Eden Queen | 2Pakistani Champion | 3Ghuroor | Pakistani Champion 2nd | Peelo Wains out |
| R7 · 4:00 Div IV 1100m |
1Mister Sardar | 2Haseeb Thunder | 3Shibra | Haseeb Thunder 2nd | Haseeb Thunder 2nd |
My three selections in the frame, by race
R1 2 of 3
R2 3 of 3
R3 3 of 3
R4 1 of 3
R5 1 of 3
R6 1 of 3
R7 1 of 3
Result type by race
R1 Upset (report)
R2 Place won
R3 Fav won
R4 Open maiden
R5 Fluke won
R6 Fluke won
R7 Place won
My selections were strongest in Races 2 and 3, and weakest at the longer distances.
The report’s opening line says Talent Again won the Makkah Joint Defence Cup and Pakistani Queen won the November Cup. The race-by-race section says otherwise: Pakistani Queen won the Makkah Cup (Race 4), Talent Again won Race 3 and Bella Two won the November Cup (Race 5). I followed the race-by-race section. Please check the official sheet.
Race 1, Maiden (1000m): Jutt Gee won. The report calls it an upset, but it was the book’s fluke before the race. Tehran Shan (my place) was second and Cheezious (my fluke) third. Tiger, the book’s favourite and mine, did not frame. In a field of 13 where I had a 9-0 horse only as a tiebreak pick, getting two of three horses into the frame is a good result.
Race 2, Division VII (1000m): My three selections filled the first three places in a different order: Zaman Sahib (my place) won, Mid Night Grace (my favourite) was second and Silent Melody (my fluke) third. I had warned that Mid Night Grace’s 22-pound rise might not hold, and it finished second. Silent Melody’s 12-pound drop worked out too. This was my best race of the day by frame coverage, and the book got two of its three.
Race 3, Division V & VI (1100m): Again my three picks filled the top three: Talent Again (my place) won, Wake Up (my fluke) was second and Thunder Pride (my favourite) third. I misjudged the order. I had put Talent Again second because of its 14-pound rise, and it won anyway. Wake Up’s 14-pound drop earned a second place. The book called the winner here, with Talent Again as favourite.
Race 4, Makkah Joint Defence Cup (maiden, 1100m): Pakistani Queen won, which was my pick as favourite. I based that on its two thirds in earlier maidens, and it paid off. Son of Gujrat (second) and Mera Sultan (third) were not among my picks. Good Day, my place, and Abra Ka Dabra, my fluke, did not frame.
Race 5, November Cup (1400m): Bella Two, the book’s fluke, won, with Tomorrowland second and Queen of Pharaoh third. Tomorrowland was my place and the book’s, so I got one in the frame. Chasing Eden (the book’s favourite and mine) was unplaced. My reading of the 2-pound weight gap with Tomorrowland did not help. Sikandar, my fluke, did not frame either, so my concern about its 16-pound rise was justified.
Race 6, Division I & II (1300m): Eden Queen won in a close three-way finish. It was the book’s fluke and I had warned about its 8-pound rise, which was wrong. Pakistani Champion was second and Ghuroor third. Pakistani Champion was my place, and Peelo Wains and Moni Prince both missed. The book’s favourite finished second.
Race 7, Division IV (1100m): Mister Sardar won as the book’s place. Haseeb Thunder (the book’s favourite and mine) was second and Shibra third. I had Mister Sardar neither as place nor fluke, preferring Singhar and Dar Princess, both unplaced. This race went to the horse I overlooked.
Day 11 summary: My selections finished in the frame 12 times out of 21, with all three of my picks in the first three in two races. I still produced only one winning favourite in seven races. The weight-drop idea worked for Silent Melody and Wake Up, while my caution about big weight rises was wrong for Talent Again and Eden Queen. In the longer races (1100m to 1400m), my picks mostly missed, so I should place less faith in my own order there.



