By Asher Butt and Abid Sultan
The book hit two favourites from six (Thunder Pride and Coach House Pari). I hit none, though several of my selections finished in the frame. One race went to an upset, two to place horses, and two as well to a fluke.
Book favs hit 2 / 6
My favs hit 0 / 6
Upset winner R1
Place winners 3
Fluke winner R5
Race-by-race results
| Race | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | Book fav | My fav |
| R1 · 1:00 Maiden 1000m |
1JK One | 2Chuppa Rustam | 3Tehran Shan | Jutt Gee out | Chuppa Rustam 2nd |
| R2 · 1:35 Div VI&VII 1000m |
1Thunder Pride | 2Mid Night Grace | 3Wake Up | Thunder Pride won | Wake Up 3rd |
| R3 · 2:10 Punjab Cup 1200m |
1Samara | 2Makhmoor | 3Counter Strike | Makhmoor 2nd | Kamal out |
| R4 · 2:45 Div I&II 1200m |
1First Love | 2Pakistani Champion | 3Farrier Star | Dubai’s Dream out | Moni Prince out |
| R5 · 3:20 Class VI 1300m |
1Sikandar | 2Ameera | 3Ceaser | Ceaser 3rd | Ceaser 3rd |
| R6 · 3:55 Div III-V 1000m |
1Coach House Pari | 2Ustrana Love | 3Safe Bet | Coach House Pari won | Safe Bet 3rd |
Result type by race
R1 Upset
R2 Fav won
R3 Place won
R4 Place won
R5 Fluke won
R6 Fav won
Race by race:
Race 1, Maiden (1000m): JK One won and nobody had selected it. In my selections, Chuppa Rustam (one of my joint top weights) was second, and Tehran Shan (the book’s fluke and mine) was third. The book’s favourite Jutt Gee and place Raees Sahib were unplaced. The maiden division has now produced an unexpected winner several times this meeting. Top weight gave me the runner-up, but not the winner.
Race 2, Division VI & VII (1000m): Thunder Pride won as the book’s favourite. My plan was to rank it third, as my fluke, and that was the wrong call. Mid Night Grace ran a surprise second and Wake Up, my favourite and the book’s place, was third. Thunder Pride dropped to 8-10 after a third at 9-0 and won comfortably. It’s a good reminder that I had it right on form and wrong on rank.
Race 3, Punjab Cup (1200m): Samara, the book’s place, won under Abdullah Amir. Makhmoor, the book’s favourite, was second and Counter Strike, my fluke, third. I had Samara in neither of my top three, and I questioned the book’s choice of it. That was my miss. Kamal, my favourite, and Sun Classique, my place, did not frame. Only Counter Strike landed for me.
Race 4, Division I & II (1200m): First Love won, as the book’s place and mine. The report calls it “Falling for First Love”, which I read as First Love. Pakistani Champion (second) and Farrier Star (third) were not among the horses I selected. Neither the book’s favourite Dubai’s Dream nor my favourite Moni Prince was in the frame. This was my best selection of the card.
Race 5, Class VI (1300m): Sikandar won as the book’s fluke and mine. Ameera, my place, was second and Ceaser, the agreed favourite, third. All three of my picks finished in the frame, though the order was wrong. That makes it my cleanest race of the day for frame coverage. Ceaser has now finished second or third at every recent Class VI start without winning. In the report it was the favourite, but in practice it behaves as a frame horse, not a winning horse.
Race 6, Division III, IV & V (1000m): Coach House Pari won as the book’s favourite. Ustrana Love was a surprise second and Safe Bet, my favourite, third. I had Coach House Pari second in my own order. The book had it first and was right. Safe Bet ran third for the third consecutive start despite its top weight.
Day 10 summary: I picked a favourite in each race and none of them won. Wake Up, Ceaser and Safe Bet all finished third, and Chuppa Rustam second. That has been the pattern all meeting: my top picks reach the frame but do not win. The book’s two wins came from horses whose weights had fallen sharply from earlier races, Thunder Pride and Coach House Pari. Where a horse has dropped 8 pounds or more from a recent run, as both of these had, I should weight that more heavily next time and treat top weight alone as a weaker signal.



